Choosing the Best Shaving Soap: Ingredients, Scents, and Tips for Sensitive Skin

Are all shaving soaps(including creams and shaving gels) the same?

No, all shaving soaps are not the same. Shaving soaps can vary in terms of their ingredients, formulation, performance, and fragrance. You have shaving gels, shaving oils and shaving creams, for the most part they are very similar and the topics below can apply to any of these terms. I'll use the term shaving soap but the term is meant to be generic to cover all of these shaving products. The key elements for a good quality shaving product include slickness, lather and post shave feel.

Here are some further details on the elements to consider when choosing a shaving product for yourself:


Shaving soaps can be made from various ingredients, including fats or oils (such as tallow, shea butter, or coconut oil), glycerin, and natural extracts. Some shaving products may contain additional ingredients like clay, aloe vera, or essential oils. The choice of ingredients can impact the soap's moisturizing properties, lather quality, and post-shave feel. Some folks prefer a crueltys-free vegan shaving soap option which is entirely plant based, others prefer a traditional tallow based shaving soap which is derived from animals.

Lather quality:

A good shaving soap, cream or gel should be able to create a rich, dense, and stable lather that provides excellent lubrication and cushioning for a smooth shave. The quality of the lather can depend on the soap's formulation, ingredients, and the water hardness in your area.

Quality shaving soap lather


Shaving soaps often come in a variety of scents, ranging from traditional barbershop scents to floral, citrus, or woody fragrances. The scent is a personal preference, and some individuals may prefer unscented or lightly scented options. It's important to note that heavily scented soaps may contain fragrance oils that could potentially cause skin irritation for those with sensitive skin. I talk more about scents below.

Skin sensitivity:

If you have sensitive skin or are prone to irritation, you may want to choose a shaving soap specifically formulated for sensitive skin. Look for soaps that are free of harsh chemicals, artificial fragrances, and potential irritants. Some folks who are sensitive to animal based products should consider a vegan option.

Performance and post-shave feel:

The performance of a shaving soap can vary in terms of its ability to provide a smooth, comfortable shave, protect the skin, and leave the skin feeling hydrated and nourished after shaving. Some soaps may have additional moisturizing properties or be better suited for specific skin types.

Post shave feel


Shaving soaps can range in price, depending on the brand, formulation, and quality of ingredients. Generally, higher-priced shaving soaps may use premium ingredients and offer a superior performance, but there are also more affordable options that can still deliver good results.

It's a great idea to read reviews, seek recommendations from experienced shavers, blogs, forums and potentially try out different shaving soaps to find the one that suits your preferences and provides a comfortable and enjoyable shaving experience. Remember, everyone's skin and preferences are unique, so what works well for one person may not work as effectively for another.

What ingredients are good for your skin in shaving soaps?

There are several beneficial ingredients commonly found in shaving products that can help promote healthy skin during and after shaving. Here are some ingredients to look for in shaving soaps and aftershave products:

Natural oils and butters:

Ingredients like coconut oil, shea butter, cocoa butter, and jojoba oil can provide moisturizing and nourishing properties to the skin. These ingredients help hydrate and soften the skin, reducing the risk of dryness or irritation during shaving.


Glycerin is a naturally occurring compound found in fats and oils, both from animal and plant sources. It is a humectant that attracts moisture to the skin, helping to keep it hydrated and supple. It can improve the glide of the razor and provide a smoother shave.

Aloe vera:

Aloe vera has soothing and calming properties, making it beneficial for sensitive or irritated skin. It can help reduce inflammation and provide relief from razor burn or shaving-related redness.  Throughout history, Aloe vera has been recognized for its soothing, moisturizing, and rejuvenating effects on the skin, making it a popular ingredient in skincare products. The Egyptians referred to Aloe vera as the "plant of immortality" and used it for various medicinal and cosmetic purposes.

Aloe plant common in shaving products

Natural extracts:

Some shaving soaps may contain natural extracts like chamomile, calendula, or green tea, which have anti-inflammatory and soothing effects on the skin. These ingredients can help calm and protect the skin during and after shaving.

Bentonite clay:

Bentonite clay is a natural ingredient that can help provide slip and glide during shaving. It also has detoxifying properties and can help draw out impurities from the skin. It can hamper a good lather, but it is a great ingredient for a shaving soap or cream.

Hyaluronic acid:

Hyaluronic acid is a hydrating ingredient that can retain moisture in the skin, promoting hydration and smoothness. It can help keep the skin moisturized and prevent dryness or tightness.

Natural essential oils:

A lot of good quality shaving soaps use natural essential oils for fragrance. These oils not only provide a pleasant scent but may also have additional benefits for the skin. For example, lavender essential oil is known for its soothing properties, while tea tree oil has antibacterial properties that can help prevent infections. Natural oils are more expensive compared to synthetic oils.


Allantoin is a soothing ingredient that can help calm and protect the skin. It has moisturizing and healing properties, making it beneficial for irritated or sensitive skin. It also works well as a gentle exfoliator.

If you have specific skin concerns or sensitivities, it's advisable to patch test a small area of skin before using a new shaving soap or consult with a dermatologist for personalized recommendations.

What are the most popular scents in a shaving soap?

The popularity of scents in shaving soaps can vary depending on personal preferences and trends. However, there are several classic and widely enjoyed scents that have remained popular among shaving enthusiasts. Here are some of the most commonly found and well-liked scents in shaving soaps:


Sandalwood is a warm, woody scent that is often associated with traditional shaving. It has a soothing and aromatic quality that many people find appealing. Sandalwood is native to various regions, including India, Nepal, Sri Lanka, Indonesia, and Australia. Each variety has a distinct scent native to where it is found.

Sandalwood shaving soap and cream scent


Citrus scents, such as orange, lemon, or bergamot (Italian hybrid of a lemon and an orange), are refreshing and invigorating. They provide a bright and uplifting experience during shaving.

Citrus scent shaving soap


Lavender is a popular scent known for its calming and relaxing properties. It offers a pleasant floral aroma that is often favored by individuals looking for a soothing shaving experience. Throughout history, lavender has been recognized for its calming and therapeutic properties. It was commonly used in herbal remedies for its ability to relieve stress, anxiety, and promote better sleep.

Lavendar scent used in shaving soap and shaving cream


Barbershop scents aim to replicate the nostalgic aroma found in traditional barbershops. These scents often combine notes of talcum powder, shaving cream, and a hint of cologne for a classic and clean fragrance.

Barbershop scent shaving soap


The word Fougère is derived from the french word for "Fern."   The scents are inspired by ferns and typically feature a combination of lavender, oakmoss, and coumarin. This fragrance category offers a fresh and green scent that many find appealing. Fougère fragrances are often associated with a sense of sophistication, elegance, and a traditional masculine appeal.

Fougère or Fern scent shaving soap image


Mint scents, such as peppermint or spearmint, provide a cool and refreshing experience. They can leave a tingling sensation on the skin and provide an invigorating shave. You will often find manufacturers release limited scents of this kind around the Christmas season in the west.

Peppermint shaving soap and shaving cream

Bay rum:

Bay rum is a classic scent that combines spicy notes like bay leaf, cloves, and citrus. It offers a unique and distinctive fragrance that has been popular in shaving products for many years.

Bay rum shaving soap and shaving cream scent

Woodsy scents:

Scents like cedarwood, pine, or vetiver (fragrant grass native to India) provide a rugged and earthy aroma reminiscent of the outdoors. These scents can add depth and masculinity to the shaving experience.

Woodsy scent shaving soap and shaving cream

It's a good idea to explore different scent options and read reviews or sample scents before committing to a full-sized shaving soap. Ultimately, choosing a scent that you find enjoyable and appealing will enhance your overall shaving experience. Be especially careful if you have sensitive skin as certain fragrances can cause irritation. I talk specifically about those scents below.

What shaving soap ingredients should I avoid?

When choosing a shaving soap, it's important to be mindful of certain ingredients that may be potential irritants or sensitizers for some individuals. Here are some ingredients that you may consider avoiding if you have sensitive skin, known allergies or want to avoid potentially harmful ingredients:

Artificial fragrances:

Synthetic fragrances are a common cause of skin irritation and can lead to allergic reactions in some individuals. Look for shaving soaps that are either unscented or use natural essential oils for fragrance. Often these scents are used because they are much less expensive to manufacturer.

Artificial fake ingredients

Sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS) and sodium laureth sulfate (SLES):

These surfactants are often used in personal care products for their foaming and cleansing properties. However, they can be harsh and drying on the skin and eyes, potentially leading to irritation. Opt for shaving soaps that are free of SLS and SLES.


Parabens are preservatives commonly used in cosmetics and personal care products to extend the shelf life of a product. While their use in shaving soaps is less common, some individuals prefer to avoid them due to potential concerns about being an irritant. Look for paraben-free options if this is a concern for you.

Synthetic dyes:

Artificial colorants or dyes are unnecessary in shaving soaps and can be potential skin irritants. Choose soaps that are free of synthetic dyes, especially if you have sensitive or reactive skin. These can be common in shaving gels.

Harsh chemicals:

Be cautious of shaving soaps that contain ingredients like alcohol, menthol, or certain astringents that can be drying or irritating to the skin. These ingredients may cause discomfort or exacerbate existing skin conditions.


If you have known allergies or sensitivities to certain ingredients, it's important to carefully read the ingredient list to ensure the soap does not contain those specific allergens. Common allergens include lanolin, certain essential oils, or specific plant extracts. It's always a good idea to patch test a small area of skin before using a new product, especially if you have known sensitivities.

Everyone is unique, and what may be irritating to one person's skin may not be a problem for another. Some people choose to avoid certain ingredients due to their potential impact on the environment. For example, some shaving soaps contain palm oil derivatives, which may contribute to pollution and deforestation.

What shaving soap is best if I have sensitive skin?

Sensitive skin ready for shaving soap and shaving cream

Choosing the best shaving soap for sensitive skin can be a personal preference, as different individuals may react differently to various products. However, there are some general guidelines to consider when selecting a shaving soap for sensitive skin:

Look for unscented or mild fragrance options:

Fragrances, especially synthetic ones, can potentially irritate sensitive skin. Opt for shaving soaps that are either unscented or use natural essential oils for a mild fragrance.

Check for gentle and nourishing ingredients:

Seek shaving soaps that contain gentle and nourishing ingredients like natural oils (such as coconut oil or jojoba oil) shea butter, glycerin, or aloe vera. These ingredients can help moisturize and soothe the skin during shaving.

Avoid harsh chemicals:

Stay away from shaving soaps that contain harsh chemicals like alcohol, menthol, or certain astringents, as these can be drying or irritating to sensitive skin.

Harsh chemicals in shaving soaps and shaving creams

Consider hypoallergenic options:

Some shaving soaps are specifically labeled as hypoallergenic, meaning they are formulated to minimize the risk of allergic reactions or skin sensitivities. These products can be a good choice for individuals with sensitive skin. The term "hypoallergenic" is not regulated by a specific standard, so its meaning can vary between manufacturers. However, the goal of hypoallergenic products is to be gentle and less likely to trigger allergic responses compared to regular products.

Patch test before use:

This is especially true if you have sensitive skin, before using a new shaving soap on your entire face, it's a good idea to conduct a patch test on a small area of skin, such as the inside of your wrist or the area behind your ear. This allows you to check for any adverse reactions or sensitivities before applying it to a larger area.

Seek recommendations and reviews:

Look for recommendations from other individuals with sensitive skin or read reviews from people who have similar skin concerns. Their experiences can provide valuable insights into which shaving soaps may work well for sensitive skin.

Barber shop shave

It may require some trial and error to find the best shaving soap that suits your specific skin needs. If you have severe or persistent skin sensitivity, it's always advisable to consult with a dermatologist, who can provide personalized recommendations based on your skin's condition.

What shaving soap scents should I avoid if I have sensitive skin?

If you have sensitive skin, it's advisable to be cautious with certain shaving soap scents that may potentially irritate or trigger skin sensitivities. While everyone's skin is unique, here are some scent categories or specific ingredients to consider avoiding if you have sensitive skin:

Strong or synthetic fragrances:

Fragrances, especially those that are strong or synthetic, can be potential irritants for sensitive skin. Opt for shaving soaps that are either unscented or use natural essential oils for a mild and gentle fragrance.

Citrus or highly acidic scents:

Citrus scents, such as lemon or lime, can be refreshing for some, but they may cause sensitivity or irritation for others with highly reactive skin. If you're uncertain about your skin's reaction to citrus scents, it's best to patch test or opt for milder fragrances.

Spicy or heavily perfumed scents:

Some shaving soaps may feature spicy scents or heavy perfumes that can be overpowering and potentially irritating for sensitive skin. It's advisable to choose more subtle and mild scents to minimize the risk of skin irritation. Some spicy ingredients include cinnamon, clove, rosemary amongst others.

Cinnamon and spice shaving cream and shaving soap ingredients

Menthol or cooling scents:

While many people enjoy the cooling sensation of menthol in shaving soaps, individuals with sensitive skin may find it too stimulating or irritating. It's best to avoid shaving soaps that contain menthol or other strong cooling agents if you have sensitive skin.

Allergenic ingredients:

Some individuals may have specific allergies or sensitivities to certain fragrance ingredients. It's important to carefully read the ingredient list and avoid shaving soaps that contain allergenic ingredients that you have previously reacted to.

Harsh chemicals or irritants:

Be cautious of shaving soaps that contain harsh chemicals or irritants, even if they are part of the fragrance composition. Ingredients like alcohol or certain artificial dyes can potentially cause dryness, redness, or other adverse reactions on sensitive skin.

Remember, sensitivity to scents can vary from person to person, so it's essential to pay attention to your skin's reactions and adjust your choices accordingly. It's highly recommended to seek guidance from a dermatologist who can offer tailored advice according to the specific needs and condition of your skin.

What ingredients provide the best slickness or lubrication in a shaving soap?

Coconut is good for slickness ingedients for shaving soap

To achieve optimal slickness and lubrication in a shaving soap, several ingredients are commonly used to enhance the shaving experience. Here are some ingredients that are known for their ability to provide excellent slickness and lubrication:

Stearic Acid:

Stearic acid is a saturated fatty acid derived from natural sources such as animal fats or vegetable oils. It contributes to the creamy and dense lather of shaving soaps, providing excellent lubrication during the shaving process.

Coconut Oil:

Coconut oil is a popular ingredient in shaving soaps due to its high content of lauric acid. Lauric acid helps create a rich lather and provides good lubrication, allowing the razor to glide smoothly over the skin.

Shea Butter:

Shea butter is a rich and moisturizing ingredient that adds creaminess to shaving soaps. It helps create a protective barrier on the skin, improving slickness and reducing the risk of irritation.


Glycerin is a humectant that attracts moisture to the skin. In shaving soaps, it helps provide additional slip and glide during shaving, ensuring a smooth and comfortable experience.


Tallow is rendered animal fat, traditionally used in shaving soaps. It contributes to a dense and stable lather, offering excellent cushioning and lubrication for a close shave. It's worth noting that the use of tallow in soapmaking can be a subject of debate and personal preference. Some individuals appreciate the qualities that tallow can impart to soap, such as a rich and creamy lather, while others may prefer plant-based alternatives.


Lanolin is a natural wax derived from sheep's wool. It has emollient properties that help soften the skin and provide superior lubrication. Shaving soaps containing lanolin are known for their excellent slickness and post-shave feel.

Bentonite Clay:

Bentonite clay is a natural clay that is often added to shaving soaps. It helps improve the slip and glide of the razor, reducing friction and providing a smoother shave.


Some shaving soaps may contain silicone-based ingredients like dimethicone, which can enhance the slickness and lubrication of the soap. These ingredients create a smooth surface on the skin, allowing the razor to glide effortlessly.

It's important to note that the specific formulation and combination of these ingredients can vary between different shaving soaps. Additionally, individual preferences and skin types can also influence the perceived slickness and lubrication. It may require some experimentation to find the shaving soap that provides the best performance for your particular needs.

Which is better, shaving cream or shaving soap?

The choice between shaving cream and shaving soap largely depends on personal preference and individual needs. Both shaving creams and shaving soaps have their own advantages and characteristics. Here are some factors to consider when deciding which one may be better for you:

Lather quality:

Shaving creams and shaving gels typically create a rich and dense lather more quickly and easily compared to hard shaving soaps. They often have a lighter and more whipped consistency, making them easier to work into a lather with a brush or by hand. Shaving soaps, on the other hand, may require more effort to create a dense lather, but they can provide a thicker and more cushioning lather once properly whipped.

Moisturization and protection:

Shaving creams generally contain more moisturizing ingredients and emollients, providing additional hydration and protection to the skin during shaving. This can be beneficial for individuals with dry or sensitive skin. Shaving soaps, especially those formulated with skin-nourishing ingredients like shea butter or glycerin, can also offer moisturizing benefits, but the level of moisturization can vary depending on the specific soap.

Moisturising is best ingredients for shaving soap

Portability and convenience:

Shaving creams are often packaged in aerosol cans or tubes, making them more convenient for travel or on-the-go shaving. They are pre-mixed and ready to use without the need for a shaving brush. Shaving soaps, typically sold in puck or refill form, require a shaving brush and an optional bowl to create a lather, making them less portable but more customizable in terms of lather consistency.


Shaving creams tend to be more affordable and readily available in many stores. They often come in larger quantities and can provide more shaves per container compared to shaving soaps. However, shaving soaps, while initially more expensive, can last longer as they require less product per shave.

Ultimately, the "best" shaving cream, shaving soap or shavings gels depends on your personal preferences, skin type, and shaving routine. Some individuals may prefer the convenience and ease of use of shaving creams, while others may enjoy the ritual and customization of lathering with a shaving soap. It's recommended to try many options and see which one works best for you in terms of lather quality, scent, skin comfort, and overall shaving experience.


Misc. At CarbonShavingCo notes: Wet shaving is a bit of an art form. It is personal to your skin type, which dictates the type of soap and shaving brush you will be using. Opting between a straight razor or safety razor (disposable razors won't be the best of experiences at all). The use of some hot water to open up your pores and soften the facial hair is a good thing. When it comes to skin conditions, such as sensitive skin, razor bumps, and at times hair growth in multiple directions extra care and consideration must be taken and avoid razor burn caused by dry shaving, lack of lubrication, wrong direction, ingrown hairs, etc. At CarbonShavingCo, the construction of our razors aims to be bacteria-free as much as possible to help avoid allergic reactions by being polished with easy to clean surface, the design maximizes the flow of debris, the pinch design reduces gaps for the collection of debris and germs, we aim to help people with sensitive skin and prevent razor burn and ingrown hairs. We believe that wet shaving is the best approach with a good shaving soap as opposed to using men's disposable razors. This also applies to safety razors for women. Keeping your gear clean is so important if you are sensitive. Join the community of wet shavers today to learn more so you can enjoy your personal spa experience.

Share this post

Leave a comment

Note, comments must be approved before they are published